administration student task rubric student work technical quality
 
Floating Pencil
Examples of Student Work
Contributed by: National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP)

Here are samples of student responses along with their score points.


Student Sample Response

  1. Now take the pencil out of the water and dry it with a paper towel. Use the ruler printed below to measure the length of the pencil that was above the water. Draw a line on the ruler to show how much of the pencil was above the water.


Level:
Adequate (3)


  1. Now take the pencil out of the salt water and dry it with a paper towel. Use the ruler printed below to measure the length of the pencil that was above the salt water. Draw a line on the ruler to show how much of the pencil was above the water.


No Score.


  1. Now use the floating-pencil test to find out if the water in the bottle labeled Mystery Water is fresh water or salt water. Do your test just like you did for the fresh water and the salt water. For this test, you can draw lines on the pictures of the pencil and the ruler below.


No Score.


  1. Look at the pencil in the fresh water. There are letters along the side of the pencil. Make sure the pencil is not touching the side of the cylinder. Note the exact level where the water surface meets the side of the pencil, as shown in picture A. Then draw a line on picture B where the water surface comes to on your pencil. This line will help you to remember where the water level comes on your pencil for the next step (4).


Level:
Partial (2)


  1. Look at the pencil in the salt water. Look at the letters along the side of the pencil, as shown in picture A. Where does the salt water come up to on the pencil? Now look at picture B. Draw a line on picture B where the water level comes to on your pencil.


No Score.


  1. Now use the floating-pencil test to find out if the water in the bottle labeled Mystery Water is fresh water or salt water. Do your test just like you did for the fresh water and the salt water. For this test, you can draw lines on the pictures of the pencil and the ruler below.


No Score.

Previous Student Work | Next Student Work

 


©1997-2005 SRI International. All rights reserved. Terms of Use