administration student task rubric student work technical quality
 
Color Dots 3
Rubric
Contributed by: New York State Alternative Assessment in Science Project (NYSED)

Maximum Score - 6 Points


1. Observations of dots 4 points total

Standard: The student describes what happens when water reaches each dot.

Point Criteria: Yellow dot, Green dot, and Black dot

  • 1 point for each reasonable description of movement or change in color.

    Acceptable descriptors:
    • climbed up
    • moved
    • smudged
    • touched the top
    • color went up
    • absorbed to the top
    • spread out
    • ran
    • raised
    • reached the top
    • smeared
    • moved upward
    • got bigger
    • blurred
    • moved off the circle

    Acceptable descriptors for color change:
    • changed color
    • fades
    • list of colors formed
    • gets higher
       
    • color thins out

***No credit is given if the student only states the dot changed.***

Criteria: Red dot

  • 1 point for each reasonable description.

    Acceptable descriptors:
    • didn't move
    • didn't blur
    • stayed as a dot
    • nothing
    • stayed the same
    • didn't wear out
    • didn't come out
    • it got wet
    • didn't come off
    • didn't spread out
    • it got soaked
    • it didn't change


2. Reasons why red dot acted differently 1 points total

Standard: The student explains why the red dot acted differently.

Point Criteria: Yellow dot and Red dot

  • 1 point for reasonable comparison of the red dot and the other dots on the paper.

    Acceptable descriptors of comparison:

  • One dot used permanent ink and the other didn't.
  • They were different solutions.
  • One dot is water color and the other isn't.
  • They were different markers or inks.
  • They are made of different stuff.
  • One is washable and the other isn't.

    UNacceptable answers:

  • They were different.
  • One moved and one didn't.

***No credit is given if the student only states the dot changed or didn't change***


3. Reasons why black dot acted the way it did 1 points total

Standard: The student explains why the black dot acted the way it did.

Point Criteria:

  • 1 point if the student explains that black is a mixture of many colors or water will separate them.

    Acceptable answers:

  • Black is a mixture (made up) of many colors.
  • The black marker was washable (water soluble).
  • All colors are part of black.
  • Water separates the colors in black.
  • Water makes the colors in black run

***No credit is given if the student only restates the observations made in question 1. ***



Highest possible score - 6 points


NYS Alternative Assessment in Science Project
NSF Grant #MDR-9154506
Copyright, April, 1996
The State University of New York
The State Education Department
Albany, New York 12234

 


©1997-2005 SRI International. All rights reserved. Terms of Use